Are Free Patterns Worth It?

I’m a member of a lot of knitting groups online, and it’s always interesting to me to see people asking for help finding knitting patterns. Often they will specify that they only want to work with free knitting patterns.

There might be a lot of reasons for this. They could be new knitters and they don’t want to spend money on a project they might not understand, or a craft they might not stick with. They might not have the budget for a $12 sweater pattern. They might have worked from free patterns before and had a good experience, so they expect that to always be the case. They might be cheap.

I would hope that they don’t want free patterns because they don’t think the work of writing patterns is worth paying for. But sometimes that’s what it feels like.

A lot of my career (at About.com, on my own blog, here at Craft Gossip/CraftBits) has been spent writing patterns that are given away. I’m generally OK with it because I’m getting paid in some way, whether from the pattern itself or because of advertising on the pattern page. But I understand that in no way does that money represent the worth of the pattern or my labor and skill used to write it. The most popular knitting pattern on my blog right now, for example, has made me a little more than $18 in the past three months, barely more than the yarn cost to knit it.

As a designer I want designers to get paid fairly, and I want knitters to feel like it’s worth it to pay for patterns when designers choose to sell them. I regularly buy patterns — more than I’ll ever make, to be honest — because I want this industry to continue.

So I guess you could say I see all sides of the issue. I’m always interested to hear other people’s thoughts, so I enjoyed reading this post from Frog & Cast called “The High Price of Free Patterns.”

It’s mostly about the disservice yarn companies do to designers by offering free patterns, because they often aren’t paying designers what they should and they don’t share in the profits when patterns become super popular.

I would love to know what you think about this issue. Do you buy patterns? Do you look for free patterns first? Have a favorite source for (free or paid) patterns? If a designer has patterns on their website for free but also sells PDFs, will you buy them? How can we all support independent designers more?

Adding a bit of knitting to your fall decor is a lot of fun, whether it’s knit pumpkins or a bunch of adorable knit ghosts like these.

Knit ghosts can be super simple like this free ghost knitting pattern from Trixie Zynch on Ravelry. Using about 50 yards of worsted weight yarn, they’re worked from the bottom up and are super cute as a pair.

This fuzzy little ghost from Forest Knitting Toys is holding a pumpkin and wearing a witch hat, though of course the accessories are optional, as is the fuzzy yarn. The main yarn is chunky and the ghost measures about 10 cm/4 inches tall. It’s worked in the round.

Another fuzzy ghost in more of a Pacman style is this ghost plushie form South Stitch Girls. It’s worked in the round with bulky yarn and includes a sweet little bow you can make in whatever color you like.

The ghost doll from Edith Grace Designs has little arms and a curl at the top of its head. The body is worked flat using DK weight yarn and you could also work it in glow in the dark yarn for extra fun. The body and head are worked in one piece with the arms knit separately.

The Grim Grinning Ghosts from Susan Claudino are super cute and you can knit them in any yarn and gauge you like to make ghosts of different sizes. These are worked in the round with the body done in one piece and the arms are knit separately. The ghosts shown were knit in sock yarn, DK and worsted weight yarn. You can find the pattern on Ravelry.

Make a ghost with funny striped legs with this ghost shelf sitter design from Claire Fairall Designs. It’s worked in three colors of DK weight yarn, and the letters spelling out boo are made with strips of garter stitch sewn into shape.

Have you read?